Is Doberman Ear Cropping Necessary?
Is Doberman Ear Cropping Necessary?
PetPlace Staff
March 21, 2023
Doberman Ear cropping in Dobermans is a common practice that has been part of the breed’s tradition for many years. This surgical procedure involves removing a portion of the dog’s ear to create an erect appearance. Typically performed on Doberman puppies between 8 to 12 weeks of age, the procedure requires trimming the ears, stitching the edges, and taping them to a hard surface to help them stand upright as they heal. It’s important that this procedure is carried out by a veterinarian experienced in ear cropping.
The Doberman Pinscher, standing 26 to 28 inches tall and weighing 60 to 100 pounds, is known for its distinctive wedge-shaped head. While some Dobermans have cropped ears, others retain their natural, hanging ears. The cropped ears contribute to the breed’s distinctive look and are often seen as part of its identity. Different ear cropping styles include the short crop, medium crop, and the longer standard show crop. Each style varies in shape and length, enhancing the breed’s striking appearance.
The Doberman Ear Cropping Procedure
Doberman Ear cropping surgery, performed under anesthesia, typically takes about 30 minutes. After the procedure, the ears are taped to help them stand upright, which usually takes 5 to 6 months, though it can take up to a year for some Dobermans, particularly with longer ear crops. The lengthy healing period can be more uncomfortable for the dog than the surgery itself, leading some to view the process as cruel and unnecessary.
Proper aftercare is crucial to prevent infection and ensure the ears remain upright. If an owner is not prepared to commit to the extensive aftercare required, they should reconsider undergoing the ear cropping procedure.
To Crop or Not to Crop?
**Is Doberman Ear Cropping Necessary?**
**PetPlace Staff**
**March 21, 2023**
**A Doberman dog that has undergone ear cropping.**
**Table of Contents**
– The Doberman Ear Cropping Procedure
– To Crop or Not to Crop?
The Doberman Pinscher is a distinctive breed, standing 26 to 28 inches tall and weighing between 60 to 100 pounds. Known for its wedge-shaped head, the Doberman’s ears may be cropped or left uncropped. Naturally, Doberman ears hang, and the tail is docked. For more on this breed, check out our Doberman Pinscher Breed Guide.
Ear cropping is a common procedure for Dobermans. This surgical process removes part of the dog’s ear to make them stand erect. Typically performed on puppies between 8 to 12 weeks old, the procedure involves trimming the ears, stitching the edges, and taping them to a hard surface for several weeks to ensure they heal upright. It’s crucial that a veterinarian experienced in ear cropping performs this surgery. For additional details, see Ear Cropping for Dogs.
Uncropped Doberman ears give the dog a different look. Ear cropping is often seen as part of the breed’s identity and character, and many believe it enhances the breed’s striking appearance. The style of ear cropping can vary from short to medium to the longer standard show crop.The Doberman Ear Cropping Procedure
Ear cropping surgery is conducted under anesthesia and takes about 30 minutes. After the procedure, the ears typically need to be taped for 5 to 6 months to stand upright, though some may take up to a year, especially with longer crops. This lengthy healing process can be more uncomfortable for the dog than the surgery itself, leading some to view it as cruel and unnecessary.
Proper aftercare is essential to prevent infection and ensure the ears remain upright. Owners must be willing to commit to this extended aftercare period if they choose to proceed with ear cropping.
To Crop or Not to Crop?
Originally, doberman ear cropping had functional purposes for Dobermans, enhancing their hearing for guarding duties. Today, it is often done to meet show standards or personal preferences. Ear cropping is an elective procedure with no health benefits, and its practice varies by region. Some countries have banned it, and while it is not illegal in the U.S., it is increasingly controversial. Some states are considering legislation to ban it, though none have passed such laws yet.
The American Kennel Club (AKC) maintains that ear cropping is important for defining certain breeds, but the American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) opposes it, citing the procedure’s purely cosmetic nature and associated risks.
Ear cropping is becoming less common, as it is not widely taught in veterinary schools, and fewer veterinarians are willing to perform it. Dog owners are also increasingly aware of the controversy surrounding the procedure. For Doberman competitors, the AKC states that dogs without cropped ears or docked tails can still succeed in dog shows.
For more information on the Doberman Pinscher, visit Everything Your Family Needs to Know About the Doberman Breed.
Ear Cropping and Its Legal Status
In the UK, doberman ear cropping is illegal under Section 5 of the Animal Welfare Act 2006, which prohibits the practice in England and Wales. Despite this, ear cropping remains legal in various other parts of the world, including the USA and Russia. There is growing concern that dogs are being sent abroad for cropping or are being imported from countries where the procedure has already been performed.
Importing dogs with cropped ears from abroad is not illegal.
Why Some People Support Ear Cropping
Proponents of doberman ear cropping often argue that it prevents ear infections and injuries from other animals. However, these claims are not supported by evidence. Ear cropping does not provide any health benefits and can actually harm a dog’s health, behavior, and overall welfare.
The procedure is primarily done for cosmetic reasons, often to achieve a specific look that some owners find desirable. While some believe that cropped ears make a dog appear tougher or more intimidating, the reality is that this procedure can negatively impact a dog’s temperament, making them more anxious and nervous around people and other animals.
How Ear Cropping Is Performed
Ear cropping is typically carried out on puppies between six and 12 weeks old. The procedure is increasingly popular among certain breeds, such as Cane Corsos and American Bullies, where part or all of the ear flap is removed. This can be extremely traumatic for the puppy and may result in permanent damage.
In some countries, cropped ears are a breed standard for certain bull breeds, while other breeds, like Dobermans, have their ears cropped and splinted.
Taping and Splinting Ears
The practice of taping or splinting is often done to achieve a specific aesthetic, giving the impression that a dog’s ears are always alert and more attractive. The ears are taped to a cardboard or wood splint to encourage them to stand upright rather than flop over.
However, there is no evidence that cropping or taping a dog’s ears provides any benefits other than for medical reasons.
